
The Indiana Humanities Council is located in the house of the late
Meredith Nicholson. "The House of
a Thousand Candles," where this famed Indiana author penned his best-selling
novel of the same name, has changed owners several times since Nicholson
sold it in 1923. With each sale, residents of the historic Old Northside
neighborhood where the house is located have hoped that subsequent owners
would preserve its rich heritage and historical significance. Indeed, residents
were outraged when, in 1933, Wald Funeral Directors wanted to convert the
beloved house into a funeral home. Wald's offer was withdrawn a few days
later because "opposition was too spirited," according to an Indianapolis Star article which appeared
May 9, 1933.
Nicholson, born in 1866 in Crawfordsville, moved
to Indianapolis at age five. Except for three years in Denver and ten years
in diplomatic service, he spent most of his life in Indianapolis, where he
died December 20, 1947, at age 81. A high school dropout, Nicholson was largely
self-educated, fluent in Latin, Greek, French and Italian. He worked at odd
jobs-- as a drug store clerk, a gofer in a print shop, and as a law clerk,
which led him to study law briefly. Abandoning a law career, he worked as
a reporter at the Indianapolis News for 12 years. During his literary career,
he wrote approximately 30 books, plays and essays before retiring from writing
in 1929 to pursue a career in diplomatic service. A stanch Democrat, he was
appointed US Ambassador to Paraguay by President Franklin Delano Roosevelt
in 1933. A year later he was transferred to Venezuela and, in 1938, to Nicaragua.
Nicholson returned to Indianapolis in 1941 and lived in retirement at the
Indianapolis Athletic Club until his death.
After selling the house in 1923, Nicholson, living briefly in
apartment 9A in what is now the Winter House Apartments, moved his family
to the Golden Hill area. Carl Taylor and his family lived in the house until
1933. President of Taylor's Carpeting Co., he urged customers to "Pay cash,
bank the difference." In 1934, the Arthur Jordan Conservatory of Music was
housed at 1500 N. Delaware when the house was sold to Mary B. Keller. During
the time Keller owned the house, it served as a restaurant (the Meredith Manor
Dining Room), a doctor's office for two osteopathic physicians, and an apartment
building. John E. Allen, the executor of Keller's will, moved into the house
in 1971 and continued to place candles in the front windows at Christmas,
a tradition begun by Mrs. Nicholson when her husband's book, The House of a Thousand Candles, became a best-seller.